Review: Heart of Glass

I received this book for free from YA Books Central in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Review: Heart of GlassHeart of Glass by Sasha Gould
Series: Cross My Heart #2
Published by Delacorte BFYR on March 12, 2013
Genres: Alternate History, Historical, Mystery, Romance
Pages: 336
Format: Hardcover
Source: YA Books Central

In a society of liars, who do you trust?

It is 1585 in Venice, and three months have passed since Laura della Scala solved her sister's murder after joining the Segreta, a powerful society of women who trade protection for secrets. Now Laura is engaged to her true love, Roberto, and she has never been happier. But the night Laura is sent on her first important mission for the Segreta, Roberto is found with the body of a dead woman in his room. Halim, an irresistibly handsome Turkish prince on a diplomatic visit to the city, identifies the woman as his sister and insists that Roberto be executed for her murder, or the Ottoman Empire will attack Venice. Laura is desperate to save both her city and her fiancé. But as the evidence against Roberto builds and Laura finds herself increasingly drawn to Halim, she begins to wonder whether everything Roberto told her was a lie. What Laura discovers is a conspiracy that involves nearly everyone she knows.

First Sentence: “I gaze down the length of the narrow blade at my enemy.”

There are, to my mind, two basic kinds of historical fiction: those that endeavor to be historically accurate and those that really don’t, merely using the lavish historical backdrop to entertain. Personally, I like both kinds. The only time the latter’s not good is when it has pretensions to being history as well as historical fiction, and teaches readers a bunch of incorrect information. Heart of Glass falls into the latter camp, and, from what I can tell, the political maneuverings of the novel have no bearing on reality. However, it’s also a fun, engaging story and written to uphold the power of women, so I really don’t mind that I’m not learning Venetian history from its pages.

Sasha Gould built this series around an awesome historically inaccurate idea she had:Venice run behind the scenes by a secret society of women. While there may not be a historical basis for this, I am all kinds of behind this kind of alternative history endeavor. All throughout history, there have been women behind the scenes affecting the course of history through their husbands, but, here, Gould is bringing them together and making them a more independent force.

These women endeavor to keep rocky Venetian politics more stable and less affected by the changes in power. They aim to be more fair and to help Venice, rather than an individual’s political aims. I love that the Segreta are shown as powerful in many ways: physically skilled with weaponry, clever, and influential. Laura herself is a perfect example of this, determined, caring and strong. I like that’s actually intelligent and puts thought into her actions, not always reacting solely with emotion.

However, much as I love this uplifting of women, I did think that Laura was a bit too powerful. She’s engaged to the Doge’s son, so she is very high in society, but I still doubt that the male councillors would ask her opinion on things. Certainly they would not with a bunch of other men in the room. The amount that even men respect her at her tender age seems rather out of place.

The only other drawback for me was the villains. Much of the mystery is very obvious and the villains have no real motivations other than grasping for power or unclear revenge. I prefer there to be a bit more depth to a villain. They ought to be somewhat understandable at least, if not relatable. Heart of Glass could have been more nuanced and had a better impact were that the case.

Heart of Glass is engaging from beginning to end, and I never found myself bored or my attention wandering. It’s a very quick read, and those who enjoyed Cross My Heart will certainly want to read this one as well. The ending left room for another book, and I suspect I’ll be reading that one too!

Favorite Quote:

“‘Would you have me silenced?’ I demand. ‘Or Emilia? Are you saying we don’t deserve a voice because we wear dresses? For shame, brother. I thought better of you.'”

5 responses to “Review: Heart of Glass”

  1. Shane Morgan says:

    Good review. I like the cover and the sound of this one.

  2. Amy says:

    I really like Cross My Heart so I think I would like this one. I loved the setting and I was intrigued by the story. I totally forgot that the sequel had come out. Great review chick!!

  3. Renae M. says:

    Since I wasn’t super impressed with book one, due to aggravating instalove, I think we’ll pass this one up. Historical inaccuracy tends to really bother me, so I doubt this would work for me at all. I like books like Anna Godbersen’s, where it’s just glamorous rich people in history that’s maybe exaggerated but still mostly in-line with real life. This doesn’t sound like that sort of book.

    • Christina says:

      Oh yeah, it’s definitely not in line with history, but I’m okay with that as long as it doesn’t PRETEND to be, though I totally get your position on it too. I thought the first book was stronger, so, yeah, not a great choice for you.

      Also, I’m loling at your use of the royal we.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge